Monday, January 10, 2011

God Forfend: Is Ed Milliband Starting To Grow On Me?

When the Labour party last September elected, rather surprisingly, Ed Milliband as leader over his older brother David, I thought that would close the door on my returning to the left wing fold in the foreseeable future. While both brothers were the supreme epitomes of the techocratic MP, David appeared to have far more political acumen as well as sounder policy ideas. Ed, on the other hand, gave off the impression of being a highly opportunistic fellow, willing to discard his old ties to Gordon Brown, the unions and the left wing, socialist divisions of the Labour party in order to gain the leadership. And that's not to mention the commiting of that most dishonourable of sins, fratricide. So young Mr. Milliband, with his deer-in-the-headlight eyes and lack of any centrist charisma, in my view would not amount to much.

All this was confirmed during his first months in the position as his first press conferences and sparrings with David Cameron across the dispatch box during Prime Minister's Questions revealed a man grossly out of his depth. He did not have a firm grasp of his policies and figures and stumbled when pressed on even the most basic of policies, until he was so hard pressed that he announced a general policy review in lieu of having to come with up anything himself. In all not a very auspicious start for a new, relatively untried leader of the opposition. Then came the questions about his private life - as an unmarried co-habitating father he had neglected to sign his name on his first child's birth certificate - and his party's inivisible presence during the university top-up-fees debates. Oh woe was Ed Milliband, who by now seemed certain to be a short-lived Labour leader.

The arrival of the New Year, however, has been kind to Mr. Milliband. The rise of VAT has for the first time signalled to the general public that the Coalition Government's policies will hurt them in their wallets and pockets, at least in the short term. For some reason - maybe his Christmas dinner brought him good fortune or he made some propitous New Year's Resolution - his first press conference (See here for a, perhaps a little overly sympathetic, live blog) of 2011 showed him in a different, far more agreeable and capable light than his first. More relaxed and in control, Mr. Milliband the Younger showed he might yet have a future as Prime Minister. That these thoughts have entered into my usually conservative mind may be because they are being roped in by my growing dislike of David Cameron, who after a strong start in Number 10 is starting to appear as a somewhat pantomime politician, incapable of making promises he can keep.

Even some of his policy suggestions are starting to make sense. To even impugn that I might find Labour ideas sensible in any way, shape or form would have been repugnant and hideous to me but a few short months ago. I especially appreciated his calling for Royal Bank of Scotland's chief executive - a state-owned bank - not to receive a multi-million pound bonus and that the unions should not strike in a coordinated fashion to bring down the government. That, Mr. Milliband the Younger says, is the job of the opposition in Parliament, not the opposition on the street. Very well, it is not yet anything I'd vote for, but if he keeps on going, Mr. Milliband the Younger will at least make me think of Labour as a party I could see running the country.

And the most important impression I came away with today is that Ed Milliband seems to believe in what he says, something that I can never recognize in Mr. Cameron these days. As we learn from Cicero, only a politician who's is convinced of the truth of his own ideas can hope to convince the voters. That is what Mr. Milliband the Younger needs to do and that is, indeed, what he seems to be doing.

Saturday, January 8, 2011

Be Wary of the Chinese Dragon

Last Thursday, the Chinese ambassador in London, Mr. Liu Xiaoming wrote an article in the Telegraph describing what he sees as a warming of ties between Britain and China. The ambassador's article comes on the eve of the visit of China's Vice Premier Li Keqiang to the UK next week. This visit, Mr Xiaoming writes, 'will bring another Chinese warm breeze to the UK.' Economic co-operation between Britain and China has been growing steadily over recent decades and, according the Mr. Xiaoming at least, the two countries share a plethora of common ideals:
'We both call on the international community to step up macroeconomic policy co-ordination and reform international economic and financial governance structures; we both uphold free trade, oppose trade protectionism and work for an early conclusion of the Doha round negotiations; we have had close dialogue and co-ordination in relation to the Iranian nuclear situation and other hotspots. China and the UK need to work together to address global issues.'

However, in light of last week's events in France, the UK and its political and commercial leaders should be aware that with China things are not always what they seem. Three senior employees of French carmaker Renault have been suspended pending an investigation into suspected industrial espionage. Now it seems that the French government is looking into possible Chinese involvement in the matter.
'A member of the DCRI [Direction Centrale du Renseignement Intérieur, the French intelligence services] told Le Point that French companies had underestimated the potential damage of industrial spying: "French companies don't have a sense of economic intelligence," he said.
He added: "This is a classic case of spying. The Chinese are masters of this and they've gone on the offensive."'
Any country that is on the charming end of a Chinese trade mission should do well to remember this: China gives with one hand and takes with the other, although the latter might be hidden from sight.

That China not always plays by the rules the West expects it to adhere to should not come as a surprise. George Grant wrote a column in the Telegraph detailing the Middle Kingdom's many rather insidious dealings 'round the world, including arms trading with countries like Zimbabwe and Sudan, not places particularly famous for their peaceful and human-rights-upholding practices. But if China's involvement in the Renault espionage case can be proven it would be a new low for China. Never before has there been any concrete evidence that it is engaging in what is usually considered unfriendly behaviour in the relations between states and a reason for the swift suspension of diplomatic intercourse.

China is still - or should that be already - too powerful for any Western country to take such steps but this espionage matter would certainly open the eyes of many government officials in the West to the true nature of the Dragon. And it should lead us to be wary of China and to not only see the piles of money but to remember the old Shakespearian (from the Merchant of Venice) line: 'all that glisters is not gold.'

Friday, January 7, 2011

Government Wants to Change Your Mind

I'm not usually one for conspiracy theories. For instance, I do not believe Prince Philip and his friends the lizard people ordered MI5 to assassinate Lady Diana; Nor do I believe that the world is ruled from a hotel called Bilderberg near Arnhem; Nor that the vaults of Area 51 are filled with UFOs that somehow keep hitting the earth without anyone noticing. So as a sceptically inclined person I scoffed at the suggestions made by Brendan O'Neill in a blog post he wrote for the Telegraph. In the post he argued that a Whitehall taskforce is trying to influence the way people behave by 'nudging' them into certain modes of behaviour. He gives three examples:
'for example, by offering less well-off shoppers health vouchers to encourage them to buy Hellman’s Light Mayonnaise rather than a King Sized Mars Bar; or by changing our local community infrastructure to make it harder to drive a car and easier to ride a bike; or by having cashpoint machines ask us: “Would you like to make a donation to a charity?”'
 O'Neill continues by invoking the terrible, nightmarish government practices of Orwell's Nineteen Eighty-Four and saying that 'the whole nudge thing is spectacularly Orwellian'.

But while I dismissed at first the entire idea as a rather simple project of subisdies by a coalition government inept at marketing its proposals properly, it was O'Neill's last paragraph that got me thinking:
'A Cabinet Office document says that because the masses make decisions “outside of conscious awareness” (ie. we’re a bit thick), the government should aim to become our “surrogate willpower”, making decisions on our behalf. In short, the authorities should colonise our minds and do our thinking for us. It is pure Big Brother. The state-approved lifestyle is no life at all.'
You see, I rather like the ability to think for myself and resent anyone, whether he be prime minister or professor or bin man, to assume that he can do manipulate the cogs and wheels inside my head. But then, as those same cogs and wheels started doing their thing, I remembered that the Lib-Dems are part of this government. And the Lib-Dems, as we all know, have no clue what to do if someone actually gives them power to do anything. So I'm not too worried about Big Brothers Cameron and Clegg puppet-mastering my every move.

What's more, governments have been doing this for ages. The last Labour government was especially prone to just throw money at a problem hoping that the mere sight of the Queen's head on a piece of paper would change peoples' minds. And if Tony Blair and Peter Mandelson didn't manage to take away our free will then I doubt this government will pull it off. What I think worries O'Neill most of all is that he assumed that a Tory government would be above such practices. But a government is inclined to try to use its power to control anything and everything. Maybe we should attempt to collectively counter-'nudge' Cameron and Clegg to stop bothering us with this transparent trickery and get on with doing something useful for a change.

Thursday, January 6, 2011

Belgium: 207 Days and Still No Future In Sight

Belgium is a country that has little to live for. Jeremy Clarkson - in one of his rare existentialist moments - called Belgium "a country invented so that Britain and Germany would have somewhere to sort out their differences." And it is true that without the interference of the Great Powers in 1830, Belgium would not have existed, but would have been split between the Netherlands and France. Now the Belgiums are coming to realize that they could have saved themselves the trouble of 180 years of national bi-linguistic co-existence. After 207 days (Dutch language alert) of coalition negotiations (Britons, take note: coalitions can take this long to form. Your five day wait was easy) everybody is ready to throw in the towel. The issues dividing the Dutch-speaking Flemish and French-speaking Walloons are too much to overcome.

The Dutch Volkskrant newspaper concludes (Dutch language alert) that Belgium now has but two options left: the first is an emergency government and the second is another general election. Neither will provide a real, lasting solution. An emergency government will eventually have to be replaced by a government with a democratic mandate and elections are unlikely to shift the political landscape so dramatically as to open up new avenues of negotiation opportunities. So what is Belgium to do? Nobody seems to know anymore.

There is, however, a third option that few appear willing to countenance: a break-up of the country into two independent states: Flanders and Wallonia. Now as most of my British friends will know, I'm not the biggest fan of Belgium. Still, I would be sorry to see it dissappear from the map. And to be honest it is unlikely to go anytime soon. The stakes are too high for everybody involved: the Walloons know that without the financial backing of Flanders, Wallonia is a dirt-poor country, with no high-tech industry to speak of. The Flemish are aware that they are to small a country to go it alone and cognizant that their only hope is to rejoin the Netherlands, which would be a national humiliation.

Finally there is the European Union. Belgium, as a bi-lingual country, is in fact a wee version of the state of EU wants to be. So letting Belgium fall apart would be to admit that linguistic differences are impossible to reconcile and, ergo, that the EU is doomed to failure. Yugoslavia, a similarly divided country was allowed to dissolve itself in the early 1990s because it was on the fringes of Europe. But for Belgium, right in Europe's heartland, to break up would be of a different magnitude, even if it will be a peaceful separation. The EU will therefore do everything in its power to prop up Belgium. Whatever it takes Belgium must be maintained.

And long may it live, for it will give the rest of us something to make fun of, this oversized border between the Netherlands and France.

On a side note, that Belgium has been without a government gives us another thing to ponder. Does a country need a government to function? Apparantly not. It can exist perfectly well with just a Parliament and some bureaucratically-minded civil servants. Who would have thunk it?

Wednesday, January 5, 2011

On the Joys of Travel Disruption

In the run-up to Christmas last December an amount of snow that would hardly have perturbed the average Moscovite, Swede or Canadian crippled the national infrastructure of Britain and the Netherlands, along with most other countries in Western Europe. Planes no longer took off from ice-covered airports, cars and trucks got stranded in snow drift-blocked motorways, and passengers were stuck in freezing trains and stations as the tracks were unusable. This post will not add to the chorus-voice of anger and shock at the inability of any company or government in any country impacted to help with the situation. Sometimes no agency 'neath heaven can do anything about the vagaries of weather.

Rather, it is about something that made me feel better about my fellow man. I myself had foolishly decided to undertake some travelling during the 'snow-storms'. First a flight home from London to the Netherlands, then a trip by train to my little brother in Maastricht, and finally a number of journeys around the country to visit more family and friends. Admittedly, I could have done without all the disruptions: a flight cancellations, long delays and detours on the trains, yet as I was stuck in airports and trainstations I observed a genial dichotomy in the behaviour of people. On the one hand there was understandable anger and annoyance at the delays, but at the same time people seemed kinder, more patient, and keener to interact with their fellow travellers.

The anger was also not directed at the sometimes hapless ground staff of the airlines and the station personnel of the railways. People understood that they themselves were almost as ignorant about the situation as the traveller himself. No, people were angry at the larger companies for their inability to inform even their own staff of the situation and the seemingly complete lack of effort to fix anything. I noticed this when, stuck at Eindhoven train station on my way to Maastricht, people joked with staff about the broken signals somewhere down the track. The NS (Dutch National Railways) member of staff showed what information he had on his little handheld device. It told him, he said, that the signal would be repaired when it would be repaired and not any sooner and at some point the NS would decide to schedule replacement bus services, but he did not know when. He said that all he knew was that the bus would come eventually, unless it got stuck in the snow too. Not a good joke, but people smiled all the same, for they realized that the chap knew as little as they did, but at least understood their predicament and sympathized.

Then, when the busses eventually came, we all got on and began to share our stories of being stuck at some small one-tracked village station waiting for a train to emerge out of the blinding-white curtain of snow; or like me, scrambling at some airport to book the last seat on the last flight to take off before ice overwhelmed the tarmack. Instead of coccooning ourselves in our little worlds of I-phone games and head-phone music, we listended and nodded and laughed with each other. For a little while we understood, to paraphrase John Donne, that we were not islands, entire of ourselves, but part of something larger.

And when the busses finally brought us to the next station where we all took trains to our separate destinations we said quick goodbyes, wished each other happy holidays, and - as I assume most people will have done - totally forgot about this brief shared experience. Still, it all made the long waits at stations and airports a little more bareable, and maybe if the harsh winters keep coming something about the joys of talking to each other, even people you don't know, may stick and teach us all a lesson about social behaviour. Or not. The dreamer that I am can hope, of course, but the cynic in me is not holding his breath. But at least I got free coffee from the NS for waiting patiently, so I'll always have that memory to look back on.

Monday, December 6, 2010

A New High (Or Should That Be Low?) In Government Incompetence?

One of the central tasks of government in the 21st century is to arrange for a stable and secure circulation of money. This is true of every government in every country in the world - except Scotland, which curiously has no government-sanctioned paper banknotes, only notes issued by seven retail banks. If the perception arises that the government can't issue money in a competent, trustworthy fashion, people will have to take refuge in other items of value. Fortunately, such a collapse of a nation's currency only happens in countries like Zimbabwe, where hyper-inflation has completely destabilized the Zimbabwe Dollar, which is now no longer issued at all. Most other countries, especially those in the West, are still to be trusted to supply secure money.

One of the few powers explicitly handed to the American Federal Government by the Constitution is "To coin money, regulate the value thereof, and of foreign coin, and fix the standard of weights and measures" (Article 1, section 8, paragraph 5). So what should we make of the following news?
"Because of a problem with the presses, the federal government has shut down production of its flashy new $100 bills, and has quarantined more than 1 billion of them -- more than 10 percent of all existing U.S. cash -- in a vault in Fort Worth, Texas."
This is incompetence of a degree rarely seen at this high, powerful level of government. In order to make banknotes safer, it has made them so safe that they cannot be circulated at all. And this at the grand, total cost of $120 million and with all the notes together representing a value of $110 billion.

And this ought to have consequences for the American Fed's second attempt at quantitative easing (QE2). Quantative easing involves pumping money into the economy to lower long-term interest rates, usually by buying debt, an analogue to printing money. But this failure to actually print that money should give us pause at the Fed's or the government's ability to accomplish their goal. Unless this is a deliberate mistake to undermine trust in the value of the dollar, thereby stimulating inflation and perhaps lowering interest rates. But I'm not knowledgeable of economics to know whether this would work or not. What I am sure of is that Barack Obama is not nearly clever and dastardly enough to pull of such a Nixonian deception. So it seems that this money printing debacle is just incompetence, plain and simple.

Espionage, Not Whistleblowing

I haven't blogged in the last week due to real life stuff that needed to be done and in the course of that week I decided to let the whole Wikileaks mania pass by without comment. I didn't really see the big deal about learning that Silvio Berlusconi is a womanizer and that Nicolas Sarkozy is an arrogant, aspiring Napoleon and that Vladimir (Batman) Putin is the real overlord of mafia-invested Russia and not Dmitry (Robin) Medvedev. Not really worthy of shouty headlines, we knew it all already.

But today, the new Aussie messiah of the internet-age, Julian Assange, from his hideout somewhere in the English home counties, has fired a broadside at the United States that defies silence. By releasing documents detailing facilities "vital to US security" he has crossed from part-time whistleblower to freelance espionage. What good does it do the free world to know that the US and Western Europe rely on a pipeline junction in Siberia for most of their natural gas and that critical Trans-Atlantic communications cables come ashore (Dutch language alert) in Katwijk and Beverwijk? Are we less free for not knowing all this?

By revealing these things, Mr. Assange and the rest of the Wikileaks crew are in fact making us less free by handing knowledge of how to threaten us to people who will gladly use that knowledge for their own nefarious purposes. If terrorists manage to strike at that pipeline junction or at facilities that make desperately-needed vaccines for typhoid or rabies, or - God forbid - get their hands on smallpox samples being used in a lab in Denmark, they can easily hold the free world at ransom or simply destroy things for destructions sake. And this does not just concern Islamic terrorists, but also anarchists in Western Europe and nationalist or communist radicals in Russia. In a dangerous world like ours, ignorance - and I hate to say this as a truth-seeking historian - sometimes truly is bliss. We sometimes need secret keepers to stand silent on the ramparts, aware of things that might terrify us and keep us awake at night.

Mr. Assange can now no longer hide behind the cover of whistleblowing. Releasing these latest cables would, in time of war, have been called aiding and abetting the enemy: a treasonable offence. Mr. Assange is in luck that he is not a US citizen, so he can hardly commit treason against that country, but he might well be charged with espionage, and he would do well to stay in hiding if he wants to remain free. Yet as far as I'm concerned, if he believes in the freedom and the importance of the word, he would give himself up now and, if required, go to the United States to face the consequences of his actions. If a brave man speaks up for what he believes in, he does not cower in the shadows afterwards, but advances "to the muzzles of guns with / perfect nonchalance!"